The Best Scone Mixes You Can
Order Online (Tested & Ranked)
Finding the best scone mix you can order online sounds simple — until you're staring at a dozen options, unsure whether you'll end up with something bakery-worthy or a dry, crumbly disappointment. We tested the most popular options so you don't have to.
Freshly baked in 20 minutes — just add cream.
Scones have a reputation for being fussy. The real problem isn't the recipe — it's the method. Cold butter, exact measurements, careful handling. Most from-scratch scone recipes have at least five points of failure before the oven even turns on.
A good scone mix removes most of those variables. But not all mixes are created equal. Some require you to cut in cold butter and add eggs. Some produce a perfectly fine scone that still tastes like it came from a box. And a rare few — the ones worth ordering online — give you something that genuinely rivals what you'd get from a good bakery.
We tested several of the most popular scone mixes available online and ranked them by what matters most: ease of preparation, ingredient quality, texture, and flavor. Here's what we found.
What We Looked for in a Great Scone Mix
Not every scone mix deserves space in your pantry. Here's exactly how we evaluated each one:
Ease of preparation
How many extra ingredients? How many steps between the bag and the oven? Fewer is better — without sacrificing quality.
Ingredient quality
We checked every label. Real fruit, minimal preservatives, and recognizable ingredients throughout.
Texture
Tender inside with a lightly crisp edge. Dry, chalky, or dense results didn't make the cut.
Flavor authenticity
If it says blueberry lemon, it should taste like blueberry lemon — not artificial flavoring with a vague fruit note.
The Best Scone Mixes You Can Order Online — Our Top Picks
After testing multiple batches across weekend breakfasts, an afternoon tea, and a bridal shower spread, here are the mixes that earned a place on our permanent reorder list.
The Scone Goddess earns the top spot for one reason that sounds almost too simple: you add heavy cream, and that's it. No cutting in cold butter. No cracking eggs. No measuring multiple liquids. You empty the bag, pour in cream, mix, cut, and bake. Twenty minutes later you have scones that are — and we mean this — as good as anything from a proper bakery.
The texture is where most mixes fail and where The Scone Goddess genuinely excels. The scones come out tender and moist in the center with lightly crisp edges — the exact balance that makes a scone worth eating. Never dry. Never crumbly. That's not just their marketing; it's an accurate description of what reliably comes out of the oven.
The flavor range is exceptional for a mix brand. Options include Wild Maine Blueberry Lemon (made with real wild Maine blueberries), Raspberries & Cream, Cranberry Orange, Apple Cinnamon Chip, Ginger Lemon, Mocha Chip, and Vanilla Chocolate Chip, among others. Each flavor uses the actual ingredient — real fruit, real chocolate — rather than relying on artificial flavoring. With over 1,100 verified reviews averaging 4.7 stars, the customer response speaks for itself.
Shop The Scone Goddess mixes →King Arthur is one of the most trusted names in home baking, and their scone mix produces a classically flavored scone with a good rise and a pleasant crumb. The tradeoff is preparation — this mix requires cold butter cut in by hand, eggs, cream or milk, and a scone pan. For bakers who enjoy working closer to scratch, that's a feature. For anyone who wants the simplest possible method, it adds meaningful steps and real opportunities for error if the butter isn't cold enough or the dough gets overworked.
Sticky Fingers is one of the most recognizable scone mix brands, stocked at World Market locations and widely available on Amazon. Their original mix produces a classic, mild English scone with a slightly biscuit-like texture. Preparation is simple — just add water — but that simplicity comes at a cost. A water-based method means the scones lack the richness that cream adds, and the result, while reliable, is noticeably less flavorful and less tender than cream-based options.
Rabbit Creek is a consistent bestseller on Amazon, largely because of their variety packs — two flavors bundled at a reasonable price. The mixes produce a decent scone with straightforward preparation, and the blueberry and cranberry orange varieties are consistently well-reviewed. Flavor and texture don't quite reach the standard of cream-based mixes, but it's a reasonable starting point for someone exploring the category before committing to a premium option.
Most gluten-free baking mixes ask you to accept a trade-off: a slightly gummy texture, a different crumb, a flavor that's good-for-gluten-free rather than just good. The Scone Goddess Gluten-Free Mix is one of the rare exceptions. Made in a dedicated allergen-free facility — not a shared facility with a cleaning protocol — it's genuinely appropriate for people managing celiac disease, not just those with a general gluten preference. Like the original mixes, it requires only heavy cream. Reviewers consistently note that family members who don't eat gluten-free couldn't tell the difference.
Note: availability is limited and batches sell out. If you see it in stock, ordering more than one is the smart move.
Shop the GF mix →How to Choose the Right Scone Mix for You
Not every scone occasion calls for the same mix. Here's a quick guide to finding your perfect fit.
Twenty minutes from mix to table. No butter required.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best scone mix you can order online?
Can you make scones without butter?
What do you need to add to a scone mix?
Are there good gluten-free scone mixes available online?
Can I order scone mixes as a gift?
The Verdict
If you're ordering scone mixes online and want the best possible result with the least possible effort, The Scone Goddess is the clear answer.
The cream-only method is genuinely foolproof, the flavor selection is exceptional, and the texture — never dry, never crumbly — is the standard every other mix in this category is working toward. Order six mixes and shipping is free. Subscribe and it's always free, delivered on your schedule, with the flexibility to choose your own flavors.
Whether you're baking for a lazy Sunday morning, setting up an afternoon tea, or looking for a food gift that someone will actually use and love — this is the one.
